Michael O'Keefe

Reverend Bill Collier

James Franco

Andy

Scout Taylor-Compton

Stephanie Baniszewski

Catherine Keener

Gertrude Baniszewski

Scott Eastwood

Eric

Evan Peters

Ricky Hobbs

Nick Searcy

Lester Likens

Elliot Page

Sylvia Likens

Ari Graynor

Paula Baniszewski

Bradley Whitford

Prosecutor

Michael Welch

Teddy

Jeremy Sumpter

Coy Hubbard

Tommy O'Haver

Director

Amy Ferguson

Sally

Brian Geraghty

Bradley

Patricia Place

Mrs. Doyle

Pamela Koffler

Executive Producer

Hannah Leigh

Shirley Baniszewski

Romy Rosemont

Betty Likens

Hayley McFarland

Jennifer Faye 'Jennie' Likens

Will Carter

Officer Waters

Tristan Jarred

Johnny Baniszewski

Carlie Westerman

Marie Baniszewski

Michelle Benes

Hope Orbach

Channing Nichols

Patty

Edward James Gage

Bailiff