Kristen Schaal

JoJo Jaconi

Christopher Plummer

Jack

Vera Farmiga

Laura

Christopher Lloyd

Stanley

Maxine Miller

Flirty Harriet

Bobby Cannavale

Leonard

Sean Tyson

Officer

Ryan Robbins

Jim

Peter Fonda

Joey

Terence Kelly

Gruff Board Member

Jill Teed

Principal Mueller

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

Serge

Chelah Horsdal

Therapist

BJ Harrison

Mary

Lewis MacDougall

Henry

Dolly Wells

Sofia

Rohan Campbell

Masked Man

Shana Feste

Director

Jennifer Besser

Executive Producer

Jess McLeod

True

Amitai Marmorstein

Cooper

Lisa Bunting

Nurse

Luis Javier

Homeless Man

Elizabeth Bowen

Griselda

Halldor Bjarnason

Jed

Robin T. Rose

Willie