Robert Forster

Old Preacher

Jim Reeve

Executive Producer

Russell Mael

Prairie Crooner

Mia Wasikowska

Penelope

Robert Pattinson

Samuel Alabaster

Fenton Quinn

Wagon Driver

Gabriel Casdorph

Anton Cornell

David Zellner

Parson Henry

Nathan Zellner

Rufus Cornell

Robert Halmi Jr.

Executive Producer

Morgan Lund

Bar Creep

Joseph Billingiere

Zachariah Running Bear

David Wingo

Barrel of Laughs

Ray Kelleher

Barkeep

Gary Brookins

Sheriff

Landon Weeks

Piano Player

Larry Zeng

Scalped Traveler

Sabrina Chappuis

Angry Traveler

Palmer Scott

Barber

Luana Zellner

Bell Maiden

Ronald Zellner

Photographer

Deanna Milsap

Bathhouse Madam

Angela Summers

Hostess Matilda

Josh Lambert

Musician (uncredited)

Toto Miranda

Musician (uncredited)

Yvonne Lambert

Musician (uncredited)