Brian Baumgartner

Skip Wick

Rhoda Griffis

Donna

Judd Nelson

Pastor Wember

Claire Bronson

Rebekah

Blaque Fowler

Drunk Rocker

Jef Holbrook

Snarky Fan

Gunner Willis

Cliff

Shawn Parsons

Chris Angelopolous

Shua Jackson

Roadie

Michael H. Cole

Jack

Sandra Elise Williams

Mimi

Andrew Eakle

Erik

Caleb Hoffmann

Scotty

Shannon Hutchinson

Sarah

Wyatt Lenhart

Michael

Matt Hoffman

Adult Erik

Alan Wells

Perry Minter

Lilly Nelson

Meg

Christina Leidel

Amy Grant

James Edward Thomas

Adult Cliff

Miles Snow

Dean Wilkie

Pete Penuel

Adult Michael

Laticia Lee

Bartender

Sean Freeland

Kasper Kapelrud

Chris White

Director

Emily Reach White

Executive Producer