Josh Lucas

Sam

Rob Huebel

Ted

Bruce Berman

Executive Producer

Kumail Nanjiani

Simon

Greg Berlanti

Director

Christina Hendricks

Alison Novack

Andy Daly

Scott

Katherine Heigl

Holly Berenson

DeRay Davis

Lonnie

Will Sasso

Josh

Josh Duhamel

Eric Messer

Melissa McCarthy

DeeDee

Bill Brochtrup

Gary

Wilbur Fitzgerald

Peter's Dad

Majandra Delfino

Jenna

Norm Waitt

Executive Producer

Scott Niemeyer

Executive Producer

Nancy Heigl

Executive Producer

Jessica St. Clair

Beth

Hayes MacArthur

Peter Novak

Sarah Burns

Janine Groff

Denise Di Novi

Executive Producer

Joe Hartwick Jr.

Executive Producer

Brooke Liddell

Older Sophie

Kiley Liddell

Older Sophie

Britt Flatmo

Amy

Alexis Clagett

Sophie

Brynn Clagett

Sophie

Brooke Clagett

Sophie

Jason MacDonald

Cousin

Tara Ochs

Cousin's Wife

Ian Deitchman

Writer

Kristin Rusk Robinson

Writer