Kristen Wiig

Maggie Dean

Ty Burrell

Rich

Bill Hader

Milo Dean

Adriane Lenox

Dr. Linda Essex

Luke Wilson

Lance

Ian Hyland

Waiter (uncredited)

Kathleen Rose Perkins

Carlie

Boyd Holbrook

Billy

Joanna Gleason

Judy

Jay Duplass

Executive Producer

Mark Duplass

Executive Producer

Jared Ian Goldman

Executive Producer

Sydney Lucas

Young Maggie

Eddie Schweighardt

Young Milo

Paul Castro Jr.

Eric

Benjamin McGowan

Cullen

Jennifer Smith

Bar Woman

Genevieve Adams

Store Manager

Truck Hudson

Security Officer

Cliff Moylan

Police Officer

David Garelik

College Dude (uncredited)

Jennifer Lafleur

Drunk Natalie (uncredited)

Noah Segura

Librarian (uncredited)

Craig Johnson

Writer

Mark Heyman

Writer