Regan Mizrahi

Diner Kid

Chris Diamantopoulos

William

Isla Fisher

Katie

Rob Corddry

Kyle

Fisher Stevens

Executive Producer

Margo Martindale

Betsy

Ebon Moss-Bachrach

Matador

Joe Pantoliano

Smitty

Jay O. Sanders

Sheriff

Jason Biggs

Anderson

Matt Malloy

Stuart

Michael Weston

Ted

Michael Ian Black

Director

Edward Herrmann

Lyle

Mark Consuelos

Morty

Audra Blaser

Vanessa

Bruna Papandrea

Executive Producer

Joanna Gleason

Lois

Edwin Freeman

Police Officer

Tim Williams

Executive Producer

Robert Trebor

Rabbi Feldman

Roger Robinson

Dr. Favreau

Heather Goldenhersh

Jane

Chuck Ardezzone

Scary-Looking Con

Kevin Allison

Hal

Teodorina Bello

Rhonda

Andrea Rosen

Woman on Bus