Gilbert Gottfried

Abraham Lincoln

Amick Byram

Marcus Thornton

Sarah Silverman

Ruth

Charlize Theron

Anna

Neil Patrick Harris

Foy

Seth MacFarlane

Albert

Christopher Lloyd

Doc Brown

Ralph Garman

Dan

Amanda Seyfried

Louise

Wes Studi

Cochise

John Aylward

Pastor Wilson

Ewan McGregor

Cowboy at Fair

Alex Borstein

Millie

John Michael Higgins

Dandy #1

Liam Neeson

Clinch

Giovanni Ribisi

Edward

Christopher Hagen

George Stark

Rex Linn

Sheriff / Narrator

Jay Patterson

Doctor Harper

Evan Jones

Lewis

Brett Rickaby

Charlie Blanche

Matt Clark

Old Prospector

Aaron McPherson

Ben

Dennis Haskins

Snake Oil Salesman

Alec Sulkin

Writer

Wellesley Wild

Writer

Kiran Bhakta Joshi

Executive Producer