Franklin Delano Floyd

Self - aka Clarence Hughes, aka Warren Marshall (archive footage)

Joe Fitzpatrick

Self - Special Agent, FBI

Karen Parsley

Self - Tonya's Friend / Former Dancer, Passions

Dr. Charles Engles

Self - Neurosurgeon

Merle Bean

Self - Michael's Foster Mother

Ernest Bean

Self - Michael's Foster Father

Billy Carter

Self - Assistant Chief, Choctaw Police (OK)

Sherry Fortson-Bailey

Self - Sharon's Friend, Forest Park Senior High

Lynn Clemons

Self - Sharon's Friend, Forest Park Senior High

Jenny Fisher

Self - Sharon's Friend, Student Council Camp

Heather Lane

Self - Dancer, Mons Venus

Michelle Cupples

Self - Michael's Babysitter

Edward Kumiega

Self - Assistant US Attorney, Western District Oklahoma

Mark Yancey

Self - Assistant US Attorney, Western District Oklahoma

Mark Deasaro

Self - Detective, St. Petersburg Police (FL)

Matt Birkbeck

Self - Author, 'A Beautiful Child' & 'Finding Sharon'

Megan Dufresne

Self - Sharon's Birth Daughter

Mary Dufresne

Self - Megan's Adoptive Mother

Ashley Rodriguez

Self -- Forensic Case Manager, NCMEC

Scott Lobb

Self - Special Agent, FBI

Nate Furr

Self - Special Agent, FBI

Sandra Willet

Self - Suzanne's Mother

Cliff Sevakis

Self - Suzanne's Father

Robert Christopher Smith

Franklin Floyd

Skye Borgman

Director