James Caan

Father McNally

Andy Samberg

Todd Peterson

Will Forte

Phil

Nick Swardson

Kenny

Susan Sarandon

Mary McGarricle (Present Day)

Adam Sandler

Donny Berger

Luenell

Champale

Blake Clark

Gerald

Leighton Meester

Jamie Martin

Barry Bernardi

Executive Producer

Rachel Dratch

Phil's Wife

Dennis Dugan

Executive Producer

Tim Herlihy

Executive Producer

Ana Gasteyer

Mrs. Ravensdale

Milo Ventimiglia

Chad

Dan Patrick

Randall Morgan

Julia Lea Wolov

Bridesmaid

Dana Goodman

Bridesmaid

Sean Anders

Director

John Morris

Executive Producer

Meagen Fay

Helen

Vanilla Ice

Vanilla Ice

Tony Orlando

Steve Spirou

Eva Amurri

Ms. McGarricle

Peggy Stewart

Grandma Delores

Ciara

Brie

Justin Weaver

Young Donny

Todd Bridges

Todd Bridges

Rex Ryan

Jim Nance

David Caspe

Writer